Navigation
Recherche
|
THR: Apple TV+’s ‘Before,’ starring Billy Crystal is an unconvincing supernatural dud
mardi 12 novembre 2024, 20:28 , par Mac Daily News
Apple calls “Before,” starring Billy Crystal, “a 10-episode atmospheric, character-driven psychological thriller about Eli, a child psychiatrist who, after recently losing his wife, Lynn, encounters a troubled young boy who seems to have a haunting connection to Eli’s past.” The Hollywood Reporter calls it “an unconvincing supernatural dud.” Daniel Fienberg: You could show me any glum, washed-out frame from Before and, even without knowing who was in it or what show it was from, I would be able to identify it as an Apple TV+ show, because there is a certain subset of Apple TV+ programming that relies on excessively dour, bottom-of-the-fish-tank aesthetics as an artificial proxy for earned sobriety. Very little is earned in Before, which is basically a flimsy direct-to-video movie from the late ’90s stretched to 10 stultifying half-hour episodes. Stripped completely of any of his familiar comic mannerisms, even when sharing scenes with a rambunctious pug who stands as the show’s most likable character, Crystal is fully convincing as a man who needs more sleep and wishes the faucets from his upstairs bathroom would stop dripping. Once I stopped caring what was happening in the show, most of my interest was put into wondering if Crystal being generally “fine” was giving Before a modicum of grounding that it didn’t deserve or if there was any chance that a more comfortable dramatic actor might have taken this thin part and somehow elevated it. The conclusion I came to was that Crystal was, if not quite mah-velous, as good as this show could get. He’s not to blame for the lack of supporting players for him to act opposite, nor for the chronologically disorienting narrative that denies him a believable arc. As a vehicle for Crystal to prove that he can be humorlessly somber, Before at least fulfills a very basic mandate. But as a spiritual thriller with supernatural overtones, it’s a lifeless dud that will do little to change that running joke about Apple TV+ being a repository of star-studded limited series you’ve never heard of. MacDailyNews Take: “Of which you’ve never heard,” but we digress. Hey, they can’t all be winners! We are currently about 1/4th of the way to being sustainable with Substack subscriptions. Not a bad start! Please tell your Apple-loving friends about MacDailyNews on Substack and, if you’re currently a free subscriber, please consider $5/mo. or $50/year to keep MacDailyNews going. Just hit the subscribe button. Thank you! Read on Substack Please help support MacDailyNews — and enjoy subscriber-only articles, comments, chat, and more — by subscribing to our Substack: macdailynews.substack.com. Thank you! Support MacDailyNews at no extra cost to you by using this link to shop at Amazon. The post THR: Apple TV+’s ‘Before,’ starring Billy Crystal is an unconvincing supernatural dud appeared first on MacDailyNews.
https://macdailynews.com/2024/11/12/thr-apple-tvs-before-starring-billy-crystal-is-an-unconvincing-s...
Voir aussi |
59 sources (15 en français)
Date Actuelle
jeu. 14 nov. - 03:51 CET
|