Navigation
Recherche
|
Mac processor comparison: Apple silicon vs Intel
vendredi 22 novembre 2024, 09:37 , par Macworld Reviews
Macworld
If you’re choosing between two different types of Macs or two generations of the same Mac, you may wonder just how much of a difference the processor will make. Since November 2020, all new Macs have featured one of Apple’s own system-on-chips based on the ARM architecture, sometimes referred to as Apple Silicon. Several Apple chips have joined the line-up, including the M1, M1 Pro, M1 Max, and M1 Ultra; M2, M2 Pro, M2 Max and M2 Ultra; M3, M3 Pro and M3 Max; and M4, M4 Pro, and M4 Max. The final Mac to move from Intel to Apple Silicon was the Mac Pro in June 2023. Now that the transition from Intel to Apple’s silicon is long complete, and it has been a while since Apple sold any new Macs powered by an Intel chip, you might think that there is no point in comparing Intel and Apple. However, some stores are still selling Intel-powered Macs and may users still have them. Those wishing to upgrade from an Intel-powered Mac to an M-series Mac may also be curious about how much of a difference to expect. With such variety on offer, there is also a question of which Apple processor is best, or at least sufficient for your needs. The current M4 series represents the fourth generation of Apple Silicon, but the M4 is still less powerful than the M1 Ultra, for example. It’s also worth noting that the difference between a Pro and Max version of Apple’s ships is all in the GPUs and memory support: the CPU is essentially the same. Here we will compare all the Mac and MacBook CPUs, GPUs, and other specs, such as RAM (a.k.a. unified memory), to demonstrate how the M1-, M2-, M3-, and M4-series chips compare to each other and their Intel predecessors. For more help choosing which Mac to buy read our buying guides where we assess the Best Mac and Best MacBook. You might also like to take a look at the article where we compare all of Apple’s chips, including those in the iPhone and iPad. M1 to M4 timeline November 2020: Apple introduced its first Mac system-on-chip, the M1 with three models, the MacBook Air, 13-inch MacBook Pro, and Mac mini. You can still buy the M1 MacBook Air at Walmart for $649. April 2021: Apple launched an iMac with a M1 chip. October 2021: The M1 formed the basis for powerful variants, the M1 Pro and M1 Max that arrived in the 14- and 16-inch MacBook Pro in October 2021. March 2022: The final M1-series chip, the M1 Ultra, arrived with the Mac Studio in March 2022. June 2022: The next generation of Apple Silicon arrived in June 2022 with the introduction of the M2 chip. January 2023: The M2 Pro and M2 Max arrived in the 14- and 16-inch MacBook Pro. The Mac mini also gained an M2 and M2 Pro chip. June 2023: The M2 Ultra arrived in the Mac Studio and Mac Pro. The Mac Studio also ships with the M2 Max. October 2023: The M3 series arrives with the M3, M3 Pro, and M3 Max landing at the same time. So far only the MacBook Pro ships with M3, M3 Pro, and M3 Max chips, while the iMac offers the M3. October 2024: The M4 series arrives on the Mac with the M4, M4 Pro, and M4 Max. The iMac has an M4. The Mac mini has an M4 or M4 Pro. The MacBook Pro has an M4, M4 Pro, or M4 Max. Which processor should you choose for your Mac and does it really matter? Read on to find out. Mac and MacBook processors compared The M1 arrived with the MacBook Air, 13-inch MacBook Pro, and Mac mini at the end of 2020. The processor inside a Mac makes a big difference to how powerful the Mac is. However, it can actually be quite confusing if you aren’t familiar with the terminology. The processor is sometimes referred to as the CPU (central processing unit), which is different from the GPU (graphics processing unit). Sometimes people will refer to the processor when they actually mean the SoC (system on a chip) that contains both the CPU and GPU. You may even hear it referred to as a SiP (system in package). We often refer to Apple Silicon as chips because they are system-on-chips that combine the CPU and GPU (and for that matter RAM, which Apple refers to as Unified Memory). The various M-series chips offer a variety of CPU and GPU cores. Similarly, there are many different Intel chips that combine several CPU cores with integrated or discrete graphics options, all of which we will discuss below. We also offer advice about how much storage, RAM and cores in How much MacBook GPU, CPU, RAM and SSD do you really need? Mac processors from Apple M1 In June 2020 Apple announced that it would transition Mac from Intel to its “world-class custom silicon.” This process began with Apple’s M1 processor, which was introduced in November 2020. It is no longer available to buy, but you may find a refurbished model. The M1 was in these Macs: 13-inch MacBook Pro (2020) MacBook Air (2020) Mac mini (2020) iMac (2021) The M1 specs were as follows: 8-core CPU (4 performance cores/4 efficiency cores) 7- or 8-core graphics processor (GPU) 16-core Neural Engine 8GB or 16GB of RAM 68.25GBps memory bandwidth 16 billion transistors The M1 was Apple’s first chip designed by Apple specifically for the Mac and it made shockwaves in the industry with giant leaps in performance. However, some people criticized the RAM limitations, with the M1 Macs only able to support up to 16GB of Unified Memory. M1 Pro Apple introduced the M1 Pro in October 2021. It is no longer available in any new Macs, but you may get one in Apple’s refurbished store or elsewhere. The M1 Pro was in these Macs: 14-inch MacBook Pro (2021) 16-inch MacBook Pro (2021) The M1 Pro specs were as follows: 8- or 10-core CPU (6 or 8 performance cores/2 efficiency cores) 14- or 16-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 16GB or 32GB of RAM 200GBps memory bandwidth 33.7 billion transistors The M1 Pro offers a 14-core GPU or a 16-core GPU. At launch, Apple claimed the GPU in the M1 Pro to be 2x faster than the M1. Apple also claimed that the GPU was up to 7x faster than the integrated graphics on the latest 8-core PC laptop chip. The M1 Pro also added a ProRes accelerator in the media engine to speed up video processing. Apple claimed that the M1 Pro could deliver up to 200GBps of memory bandwidth, which is nearly 3x of the bandwidth of the M1. The M1 Pro supports up to 32GB RAM (compared to a maximum of 16GB for the M1). M1 Max The M1 Max was also introduced in October 2021 as a standard option for the 16-inch MacBook Pro and a build-to-order option for the 14-inch MacBook Pro. Then in March 2022, the M1 Max became one of the options for the Mac Studio. The M1 Max is no longer available in any new Macs, but you may get one in Apple’s refurbished store or elsewhere. The M1 Max was in these Macs: 14-inch MacBook Pro (2021) 16-inch MacBook Pro (2021) Mac Studio (2022) The M1 Max specs are as follows: 10-core CPU (8 performance cores/2 efficiency cores) 24- or 32-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 32GB or 64GB of RAM 400GBps memory bandwidth 57 billion The M1 Max has the same 10-core CPU as the M1 Pro, but everything else is significantly enhanced. The GPU is probably the most important difference between the M1 Pro and M1 Max. The M1 Max GPU goes all the way up to 32 cores (there is also a build-to-order 24-core option.) At launch, Apple claimed the graphics performance of the 32GB GPU to be up to 4x faster than the M1. M1 Max also has two ProRes accelerators that help it deliver up to 2x faster video encoding than M1 Pro. Apple claimed the M1 Max-powered MacBook Pros can edit up to 30 streams of 4K ProRes video or up to seven streams of 8K ProRes video in Final Cut Pro. That’s more streams than on a 28-core Mac Pro with Afterburner. At launch, Apple stated that the performance of the M1 Max is “similar to that of the highest-end GPU in the largest PC laptops while using up to 100 watts less power.” M1 Max also offers up to 400GBps of memory bandwidth. That is 2x that of M1 Pro and nearly 6x that of M1. As a result, a maximum of 64GB RAM is possible with the Max. M1 Ultra The M1 Ultra was also introduced in March 2022 as an option for the Mac Studio. You may still find a 2022 Mac Studio available, potentially at a good discount. The M1 Ultra was in the: Mac Studio (2022) The M1 Ultra specs were as follows: 20-core CPU (16 performance cores/4 efficiency cores) 48- or 64-core GPU 32-core Neural Engine 64GB or 128GB of RAM 800GBps memory bandwidth 114 billion transistors The M1 Ultra is essentially two M1 Mac chips, so it can offer a 20-core CPU and up to 64-core GPU. Apple achieves this using UltraFusion architecture to connect the two M1 Max chips to avoid trade-offs such as increased latency, reduced bandwidth, and increased power consumption. Apple also explained that the M1 Ultra behaves like, and is recognized by software, as one chip. At launch Apple claimed to offer “4x the bandwidth of the leading multi-chip interconnect technology” and that the M1 Ultra “delivers 90 percent higher multi-threaded performance than the fastest available 16-core PC desktop chip in the same power envelope.” Apple also claimed that the 64-core GPU delivers faster performance than the highest-end PC GPU available – all while using 200 fewer watts of power. The M1 Ultra can be configured with up to 128GB unified memory; according to Apple the most powerful PC graphics cards maxed out at 48GB. The M1 Ultra also offers twice the media engine capabilities of the M1 Max, for accelerated video encoding and decoding. M2 Apple 13-inch MacBook Air (M2, 256GB/16GB RAM, 2024) The M2 was introduced in June 2022 with the MacBook Air and 13-inch MacBook Pro. Apple later added the M2 as an option for the Mac mini in January 2023, and a new 15-inch MacBook Air in June 2023. The M2 is still featured in: 13-inch MacBook Air (2022) (buy from Apple here) – Note: Apple updated this model in October 2024 and it now includes 16GB RAM as standard. The M2 was in these Macs: Mac mini (2023) 15-inch MacBook Air (2023) 13-inch MacBook Pro (2022) The M2 specs were as follows: 8-core CPU (4 performance cores/4 efficiency cores) 8- or 10-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 8GB, 16GB or 24GB of RAM 100GBps memory bandwidth 20 billion transistors At launch, Apple claimed: “Compared with the latest 10-core PC laptop chip, the CPU in M2 provides nearly twice the performance at the same power level.” Apple also stated that the “M2 provides nearly 90 percent of the peak performance of the 12-core chip while using just one-fourth the power.” Apple also claimed the 10-core GPU delivers “up to 25 percent higher graphics performance than M1 at the same power level”, thanks to the larger cache and higher memory bandwidth. At maximum power this is 35 percent better, claimed Apple. Thanks to the additional GPU cores, 10 cores rather than the 8-core limit of the M1, the M2 performs better than the M1, but it’s still below the M1 Pro with 14 cores. M2 Pro The M2 Pro was introduced in January 2023 with the 14- and 16-inch MacBook Pro and the M2 Pro Mac mini. It is no longer available from Apple. The M2 Pro was in these Macs: 14-inch MacBook Pro (early 2023) 16-inch MacBook Pro (early 2023) Mac mini (2023) The M2 Pro specs were as follows: 10-core or 12-core CPU (6 or 8 performance cores/2 efficiency cores) 14- or 16-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 16GB or 32GB of RAM 200GBps memory bandwidth 40 billion transistors Like the M1 Pro, the M2 Pro has a built-in media engine that accelerates H.264, HEVC, and ProRes video encoding and decoding. Better power efficiency during playback of multiple streams of 4K and 8K ProRes video can also be expected. At launch Apple claimed that the M2 Pro is 40 percent faster in Adobe Photoshop image processing, and 25 percent faster in Xcode code compiling when compared to the M1 Pro. Apple claimed that, when compared to the Core i9 16-inch MacBook Pro, the M2 Pro is 2.5 times faster in Photoshop and 80 percent faster in Xcode. M2 Max Apple Mac Studio (M2 Max, 2023) Read our review Price When Reviewed: 2 399 € Best Prices Today: €2399 at Apple | €2399 at Cdiscount FR | €2399 at Darty FR The M2 Max was also introduced in January 2023 with the 14- and 16-inch MacBook Pro. The M2 Max still features in this Mac: Mac Studio (2023) (buy from Apple here) The M2 Max was in these Macs: 14-inch MacBook Pro (2023) 16-inch MacBook Pro (2023) The M2 Max specs are as follows: 12-core CPU (8 performance cores/4 efficiency core) 30- or 38-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 32GB, 64GB or 96GB of RAM 400GBps memory bandwidth 67 billion transistors Like the M1 Max, the M2 Max offers two video-encode engines and ProRes engines. At launch, Apple claimed the M2 Max would see a 30 percent improvement over the M1 Max when using color grading in DaVinci Resolve, while it would be 2 times faster than the Intel Core i9 MacBook Pro in the same test. For effects rendering in Cinema 4D, Apple claimed that the M2 Max is 30 percent faster than the M1 Max, and 6 times faster than the Core i9 MacBook Pro. M2 Ultra The M2 Ultra arrived in June 2023. It is still an option for both the Mac Studio and the Mac Pro. Apple Mac Studio (M2 Ultra, 2023) Apple Mac Pro (M2 Ultra, 2023) The M2 Ultra still features in these Macs: Mac Studio (2023) (buy from Apple here) Mac Pro (2023) (buy from Apple here) The M2 Ultra’s specs are as follows: 24-core CPU (16 performance cores/8 efficiency core) 60- or 76-core GPU 32-core Neural Engine 64GB, 128GB or 192GB of RAM 800GBps memory bandwidth 134 billion transistors M3 The M3 arrived at the end of October 2023. Apple 13-inch MacBook Air (M3, 256GB/16GB RAM, 2024) Apple 15-inch MacBook Air (M3, 256GB/16GB RAM, 2024) The M3 is still featured in: 13-inch and 15-inch MacBook Air (2023) (buy from Apple here) – Note: Apple updated this model in October 2024 and it now includes 16GB RAM as standard. The M3 was in these Macs: iMac (2023) 14-inch MacBook Pro (2023) The M3 specs are as follows: 8-core CPU (4 performance cores/4 efficiency cores) 8- or 10-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 8GB, 16GB or 24GB of RAM 100GBps memory bandwidth 25 billion transistors M3 Pro The M3 Pro also arrived at the end of October 2023. It was an option for both the 14-inch MacBook Pro and the 16-inch MacBook Pro. Apple 14-inch MacBook Pro (M3 Pro, 2023) Read our review Apple 16-inch MacBook Pro (M3 Pro, 2023) The M3 Pro was in these Macs and you may find some still available to buy from resellers at a discount: 14-inch MacBook Pro (2023) 16-inch MacBook Pro (2023) The M3 Pro specs are as follows:: 11- or 12-core CPU (5 or 6 performance cores/6 efficiency cores) 14- or 18-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 18GB or 36GB of RAM 150GBps memory bandwidth 37 billion transistors M3 Max Like the other M3 chips, the M3 Max arrived at the end of October 2023. It was an option for both the 14-inch MacBook Pro and the 16-inch MacBook Pro. Apple 14-inch MacBook Pro (M3 Max, 2023) Apple 16-inch MacBook Pro (M3 Max, 2023) Read our review The M3 Max was in these Macs. You may find them still available to buy from resellers at a discount: 14-inch MacBook Pro (2023) 16-inch MacBook Pro (2023) The M3 Max specs are as follows: 14- or 16-core CPU (10 or 12 performance cores/4 efficiency cores) 14- or 18-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 36GB, 48GB, 128GB of RAM 300GBps or 400GBps memory bandwidth 92 billion transistors M4 The M4 was introduced in October 2024. It is available in the iMac, Mac mini, and 14-inch MacBook Pro. Apple 14-inch MacBook Pro (M4) Read our review Apple Mac mini (M4) Apple iMac (M4) Read our review The M4 is featured in these Macs: iMac (2024) (buy from Apple here) Mac mini (2024) (buy from Apple here) 14-inch MacBook Pro (buy from Apple here) The M4 specs are as follows: 8- or 10-core CPU (4 performance cores/4 or 6 efficiency cores) 8- core 10-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 16GB, 24GB, 32GB of RAM 120GBps memory bandwidth 28 billion transistors M4 Pro The M4 Pro was introduced in October 2024. It is available in the Mac mini, and 14- and 16-inch MacBook Pro. Apple 14-inch MacBook Pro (M4 Pro) Apple Mac mini (M4 Pro) Read our review The M4 Pro is featured in these Macs: Mac mini (2024) (buy from Apple) 14-inch MacBook Pro (buy from Apple) 16-inch MacBook Pro (buy from Apple) The M4 Pro specs are as follows: 12- or 14-core CPU (8 or 10 performance cores/4 efficiency cores) 16- or 20-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 24GB, 48GB of RAM 273GBps memory bandwidth M4 Max The M4 Max was introduced in October 2024. It is available in the 14- and 16-inch MacBook Pro. Apple 16-inch MacBook Pro (M4 Max) Apple 14-inch MacBook Pro (M4 Max) The M4 Max is featured in these Macs: 14-inch MacBook Pro (buy from Apple) 16-inch MacBook Pro (buy from Apple) The M4 Max specs are as follows: 14- or 16-core CPU (10 or 12 performance cores/4 efficiency cores) 32- or 40-core GPU 16-core Neural Engine 36GB, 48GB, 64GB, 128GB of RAM 410GBps or 546GBps memory bandwidth Mac Processor Benchmarks The benchmarks below include the M4, M4 Pro, and M4 Max which were released in the latter part of 2024. The M4 Ultra has not been released, and Apple never released an M3 Ultra, so the Mac Studio and Mac Pro still use the M2 Ultra, which as you can see, is not the fastest anymore, but still among the top performers. M1 vs Intel: Benchmarks As for how Apple’s silicon compares to the Intel processors that used to power Macs, when we tested we found that even Apple’s M1 chips delivered a performance that was equal to, or even better, than the most powerful Intel laptop chips found in Macs at the time and the M1 Macs weren’t even targeted at the kind of people who need the most powerful laptops. The M1 really was better than a comparable Intel chip–just as Apple claimed when it launched. As you can see from the benchmarks above and below, there is no reason to avoid buying an M1-, M2-, M3-, or M4-series Mac over any Intel-powered Mac. Even the iMac with M3 beats the fastest iMac Pro (with a 2.3GHz Intel Xeon W-2191B) by some margin. Results are expressed as Geekbench scores. Higher scores/longer bars are faster. M1 vs Intel: What’s the difference between Apple Silicon and Intel? The Intel processors that Apple used in its Macs since 2006 were x86 chips. Apple Silicon is based on ARM but includes a number of Apple technologies (so they aren’t ARM chips, strictly speaking). ARM and x86 are completely different architectures-which means that they need different code, and hence the operating systems and software need to be tailored to them. Therefore one of the main concerns with the move to Apple Silicon (M1, M2, M3, or M4) could be whether the required software is compatible with ARM. Apple addressed this with Rosetta 2, which translates the code from x86 to ARM and, with a few exceptions, there was no issue with software written for x86 running on the M1 Macs. Many software developers were quick to update their software to run on M-series Macs, though. The M1-series Macs were a huge step up from the equivalent Intel models. One advantage of ARM over Intel’s X86 is power consumption, this is evident in the long battery life of the M-series Macs. The 16-inch MacBook Pro has the longest-ever battery life for a Mac at 24 hours. The 2019 Intel-powered 16-inch MacBook Pro could only manage 11 hours. There are other ways in which the M-series chips are more efficient than Intel processors. Macs with Apple chips have two kinds of processor cores: high-performance and efficiency. Having two types of cores ensures that background processes don’t slow down the computer because there is always enough power available for programs to run. For example, even the fastest Intel-powered Mac might have experienced slowdowns and performance drops if a system process like iCloud, or the indexing of Photos or Spotlight, was running in the background. This is all great in theory, but in practice, the benchmarks prove that there is a leap in performance from Intel to M1 and beyond. Mac processors made by Intel If you bought your Mac before the end of 2020 it will have Intel inside. Apple has used various generations of Intel processors over the years. Here are details of some of the Intel chips you may find inside any Macs that predate Apple’s move to the M1 and beyond. Apple no longer sells Macs with Intel processors, not even old models in the Apple Certified Refurbished Store. If you are considering buying a used Intel-powered Mac we would recommend that you don’t! Read Should I buy a secondhand Mac? Back when Macs were powered by Intel, Apple specified an Intel processor generation for each Mac in its marketing materials. So you would have seen a description such as ‘2.0GHz quad-core 10th-generation Intel Core i5 processor’ associated with a particular Mac. However, without those marketing materials, it isn’t so easy to find out which processor is inside an Intel-powered Mac because the About This Mac information shows the year that Mac went on sale and the processor specifics such as GHz and the number of cores, but not the processor generation. Identifying the processor generation can be useful in comparing different Macs – and PCs. If you want to find out the specs of your Intel Mac we suggest you read our guide to how to check the specs of your Mac. Here’s how the Intel processor lineup has looked since around 2011: 1st Generation – Nehalem (2011) 2nd Generation – Sandy Bridge (2011) 3rd Generation – Ivy Bridge (2012) 4th Generation – Haswell (2013) 5th Generation – Broadwell (2015) 6th Generation – Skylake (2015) 7th Generation – Kaby Lake (2017) 8th Generation – Coffee Lake (2018) 9th Generation – Coffee Lake Refresh (2018) 10th Generation – Ice Lake (2019) How to choose a Mac processor Whether you are comparing two Macs with Apple chips, or one Apple chip and one Intel chip, or even two Intel chips, this is what to consider: How many CPU cores? You will notice that Apple’s M1 has eight CPU cores, the M1 Pro and M1 Max have ten CPU cores, and the M1 Ultra has 20 CPU cores. The M2 series extends that, with the M2 CPU having 10 or 12 CPU cores, the M2 Pro and M2 Max having a 12-core CPU, and the M2 Ultra having 24 cores. That extension continues with the M3 and M4 and will keep going with future chips. Among the Intel Macs, you would generally find dual-core, quad-core, 6-core, 8-core, and 10-core CPUs, while the Mac Pro offers a Xeon processor with 8, 12, 16, 24, or 28-cores. Having more cores available means that your Mac will be able to run multiple processes at once. Apple’s M-series Macs have two kinds of cores: high-performance and high-efficiency cores. The difference between high-performance and efficiency cores is that the efficiency cores are power-saving while the performance cores can be used for more demanding tasks. So while the performance cores focus on demanding tasks there won’t be a hit on power-efficient processing, both can happen in tandem. How many GPU cores? This is more apparent on the M-series Macs because Apple highlights the number of GPU cores and this extends as you move up the range
https://www.macworld.com/article/670873/which-mac-processor-apple-processor-comparison-m1-vs-intel.h
Voir aussi |
59 sources (15 en français)
Date Actuelle
lun. 23 déc. - 03:46 CET
|