Tech Critics Create Powerful Video Responding To IBM's 'Dear Tech' Ad

'Technology hasn't fallen short of its promise. Tech companies have,' argues Evan Selinger, a philosophy professor at Rochester Institute of Technology, reporting on a new 'collaborative video response to IBM's Dear Tech Ad' (which was aired during last week's telecast of the Oscar's). Earlier Selinger wrote:

[IBM's] infantilizing ad depicts technology as if it were an autonomous person, a benevolent Santa Claus figure that can give great products to all the good little girls and boys if they ask politely.... It all sounds nice. But the message obscures the fact that technology hasn't fallen short of its promise. It's recalcitrant tech companies that need to change. That includes IBM....
IBM isn't alone in this sunny disingenuousness. Its competitors also give lip service to listening to our hopes and dreams while shutting down criticism that's voiced to make things better... A commercial like this one can't avoid being an empty marketing pitch when it represents a contested concept as a clear and unambiguous wish that technology can magically grant just as easily as Santa can satisfy a request for a new smartphone.

So a team of tech critics including Joy Buolamwini of the MIT Media Lab 'created an alternative to IBM's ad. It's a provocative, line-by-line, video counterstatement' -- not 'Dear Tech,' but 'Dear Tech Company.'
Here are some of its more provocative quotes:

Read more of this story at Slashdot.